sig p220 vs 1911 recoil

Given the size of the P227's grip makes it hard to recommend over other double-stack .45s like the HK45, HK USP, CZ 97, SAR K2-45, or even striker-fired guns like . I think a CZ 97B might be a closer comparison in manual of arms at least to a 1911 since it has a manual safety and not a decocker like a DA/SA P220. My friend Chuck Taylor is one of the leading authorities on combat handguns and the author of a great many articles and multiple books on the topic. Thats cool; this article is my personal opinion. Now lets take a look at the design defects of this handgun. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Its subjective to a point, but there is an objective answer in there when one considers truly having to fight for their life. In stock. My Sig P220 SAO 10mm pistol does have a steel frame. John 3:16 For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. This is a proven pistol that offers superlative reliability and surprising accuracy. Something to think about before you pick up that 1911. Heres the short version answer why Sig P220 trumps the 1911: Now heres the long version of this bickering: Ive always been a Sig Sauer fan and it all started when I got my first Sig Sauer P226 then wandered over to the P220 in .45 ACP years ago. Engineered with a nearly straight-line feed, the P220 was reliable with almost every hollow-point bullet. My Colt is an early model blued steel model and my Sig does have an aluminum frame. . For those looking for an excellent mid-sized carry 1911, check out the 4.25-inch commander S&W 1911SC E-Series. Its straight, groove-free, with a very comfortable palm swell at the bottom of the grip. I like them both very much but I also have a P226 stainless and if I were transitioning to .45 caliber I'd first go with the P220 then later chose the 1911 as your next platform. Today, Im going to review two Viridian laser products: one for your pistol and one for your AR. The more modern base models sport a rail for a light or laser, as well as night sights. Required fields are marked *. I have both a Colt Delta Elite and a Sig P220 DAO in 10 mm. All SIG pistols and products are fine weapons, but this one is particularly impressive. He deployed in 2009 to Afghanistan and again in 2011 with the 22nd MEU(SOC) during a record setting 11 months at sea. The double action trigger is heavier and longer, but still very smooth and very compliant to trigger pull. Developed by the German-Swiss arms manufacturer Sig Sauer for the competition to replace the M1911A1, the P226 had come in second place to the M9. With a hair more pressure you get the trigger break. At the time this was a combat handgun that was hard to beat and shooting is taking a step back to the Cold War. My GunsAmerica search brought up the following: Smith & Wesson, two Colts, Kimber, CSC Arms, Springfield, Dan Wesson, Detonics, Taurus, and Ruger. They are different animals outside of the caliber. Yeh, it was lust at first sight. +1 Just received my Sig P220 Stainless Elite about 2 weeks ago. A forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer Pistols and SIG Sauer Rifles owners and enthusiasts. Is Colts customer service widely lauded as exceptional? Even the Delta Elite made some frame modifications after the earlier models cracked. The SIG P220 is a fascinating firearm from an intriguing era. Those P220 variants are easier on those who cant wrap their heads around two different trigger pulls from one gun. While the P220 is mostly known as the 45 ACP SIG, it's been produced in a ton of different calibers, including 9mm, 7.65x21mm Parabellum, .38 Super, and of course, 10mm. If you have a tight budget but want a high-quality pistol, you can get these guns for around 400 bucks. The SIG is a hammer fired, SA/DA pistol. The full-length slide rails are on the inside of the frame, which lets the slide sit deeper, lowering the bore axis to reduce felt recoil and muzzle flip. Have never found ANY other pistol capable of doing that, reliably, all the time. Sport Type: Hunting. All pistols have drawbacks and shortcomings. Who makes the first ten guns that pop up? I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. It's beyond a stretch to call that an "evolution"they are different animals. Its easy to reach, and the thumb can quickly drive it downwards. These handy units are the only part of a Sig P365 you need to go to a gun shop to receive. I would have whole-heartedly said 1911..UNTIL I shot my first p220. Spin the takedown lever downward, and the slide is then unlocked and removable from the frame. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! The Swiss Army needed a new pistol to take the position of the SIG P210. Ill get more into this aspect a little . ), load them in the magazine, and then feed them through the pistol, one after another. Colt 1911 It comes down to whats more important for you, reliability/accuracy/ergonomics, or capacity/size? Ive another example of the W. German mfgd P220 built with the classic European magazine release at the bottom of the grip. The SIG 220s, 226s and 1911s are all awesome. Have not had an issue with shooting either one and I enjoy both, fell in love with the P220 when they first came out. The Commander, originally introduced in lightweight format in 1949, weighed 26.5 ounces unloaded and held the same number of .45, .38 Super, or 9mm rounds as the P220. "Nothing is easier than the expenditure of public money. Travis is a former Marine Machine gunner who served with 2nd Bn 2nd Marines for 5 years. Sig Sauer P226 Legion Full-Size 9Mm 4.4" 15Rd. Of the three the CZ 97 is my favorite by a good bit. The P220 weighs a tad less than a lightweight Commander, 25.7 ounces unloaded. Magazines Magazines. Sig Sauer Recoil Springs - 14, 16, 18 and 20 Lbs.Fits all P220, P226, P227 models (DASA, SAO, Elite, Legion, 220/226 "S" etc.) The . It always had good sights compared to most of its competition. It fires the much more powerful .45 ACP cartridge, but despite its greater power it kicks less and is more pleasant to shoot than most snubbies. Just letting you know. 10mm models of the SIG P220 are great as hunting pistols, especially with an optic involved. High among these was the double-action first shot mechanism. However, none of this changes the other SIG attributes that made the P220 a favorite. I think that the Sig P 220 is an evolutionary development from the 1911. Posts: 2,550. Hmmm, interesting. The SIG-Sauer pistols are famous for accuracy across the board, but the P220 may be the most accurate of them all. Most 1911 pistols of the period were not throated by their manufacturers to feed wide-mouth hollow-point bullets, the choice of most police and gun-wise private citizens. And, of course, it is much faster to reload, and its flat magazines are much more discreet and comfortable to carry than speedloaders for a revolver when concealment is the order of the day. Remington? It will probably need a fluff n buff to make it feed defensive ammo, too. The SIG Sauer P220 is a semi-automatic pistol. Based on design, I would say the P220 is a stronger pistol. The gun was and is extremely reliable. I will be in the market for a 45 in the next couple months and am looking for my first 45. GRD-SIG-22F-SS. The P220 operates by the locked breech short-recoil method pioneered by John Browning. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. The TISAS 1911A1 with a WWII-like holster and mag pouch available from Sarco. The gun lacks manual safety. Flip a coin. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. They are two distinct animals other than the commonality of caliber. (not CA). Massad Ayoob. In the 90s the gun community widely reported both the Colt Delta Elite and S&W FBI 1076 pistols couldn't hold up to full power 10mm- there were numerous frame failures and the FBI sent back many if not most of their new 1076 models for this reason. For a while, it came to the United States as a Browning BDA model. Massad Ayoob is one of the world's outstanding handgunners and is the Director of Massad Ayoob Group. It plowed through almost 300 rounds without so much as a hiccup or a cleaning. BONUS OFFER: Get your free shooting range targets to print at home! Then I can finish the trigger pull to ensure a very well placed shot. Kimber Aegis Elite Custom (sold); 9mm Springfield Loaded Stainless (sold); Kimber Stainless Custom II (sold); Dan Wesson Valor; Les Baer Custom Carry (sold); Wilson Combat X Tac; Guncrafter Industries No Name (sold); Springfield 1911-A1 "Custom . Massad Ayoob confesses that the SIG P220 is his very favorite SIG pistol, and indeed, one of his all-time favorite handguns. Yet most officers found it at least as pleasant to shoot as the full size 1911A1 in the all-steel configuration, which weighed some 39.5 ounces. When you buy a P220, you know youre getting a quality gun. Who sells it? That is all there is to it. P220 All steel hands down. Easy to DisassembleThis is just another thing that these two crowds will bicker over. I have owned several 1911s and a P220 Compact, single action. This West German SIG P220 is a 1969 Mustang. But it doesnt need one as it has a DA/SA trigger The first trigger pull is double-action, which means the trigger pull is long and heavy. 1. kygunco.com . Now, lets look at plainclothes wear, whether in a detective assignment or off duty. Both are awesome handguns. Best Selling Rifles; . Furthermore, its mechanical performance leaves nothing to be desired. I'm in the same boat and recently decided a 220 -- or 227 if I can find one -- will be my next purchase. When the cheesey stamped sheet metal roll pins are removed for cleaning of the frame or repair they will not go back in as tight and should be replaced. Both are absolutely fantastic firearms. DA/SA Full-Sized Pistol Chambered in 45 ACP . Ive had both, for me, the sig is hands down the best platform foe ten mil. However, unlike a traditional 1911 (or even a SIG Sauer X-Five SAO), the Legion SAO's thumb safety does not lock the slide. Right off, I'm referring specifically to the Legion. The pistol's formal designation as of 1940 was Automatic Pistol, Caliber .45, M1911 for the original model of 1911 or Automatic Pistol, Caliber .45, M1911A1 for the M1911A1, which was adopted in 1924. For generations, officers carried little 2-inch .38 caliber revolvers as off-duty guns, simply for their light weight and convenience. Check Price . The SIG Sauer P220 introduced the SIG Sauer system, which is more straightforward than the P210 and does away with the grooves in the slide and barrel as well as the locking lugs. Designed by John Browning, the M1911 is the best-known of his designs to use the short recoil principle in its basic design. [#11] I'd go with the P229 and the E2 grip. The pistol was also used in police enforcement and military duties in Denmark and Japan. Add to Cart. Its a massive gun with a big, wide grip a bit bigger than it needs to be. I grew to like it more and was carrying it lots until that fateful Sig Sauer fell in my lap courtesy of a friend. What a wonderful gun to run. A forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer Pistols and SIG Sauer Rifles owners and enthusiasts. Done. The guns recoil is minimal and best described with an Awe. The weight helps cut recoil, and the fat bottom grip helps displace it in the hand. It is in fact a corrosion-resistant PVD coating in "Legion Gray.". It was so much fun shooting that after one shooting session I went out and bought a Sig P229, but I had wanted another P226 in .40 but the store didn't have one, but now I am glad because I like having the two different sizes. It also has a fully adjustable rear sight, and the magazine holds 14 rounds of ammo. The only thing the P220 and 1911 share in common is caliber. Its very well balanced & sits very well in the hand (much more instinctively than my Glock 26), and its very, very accurate the author is spot on with his comments. They all worked just fine afterwards. They paid the price of a reduced in-gun cartridge capacity, only five to six rounds. See less See more Reply. Get the 76th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. Compared to the P210, the P220 is a far superior firearm in terms of performance and aesthetics. $19.95. I know most of you 1911 guys and gals are sputtering, yeah, but! and stating counterpoint after counterpoint based on different models and options and personal opinions. Sig P220 Combat - Much lighter (follow ups are slightly slower, recoil is more jumpy), tougher and more durable, fits with my active rugged lifestyle, double action and stupid simple, easy to carry. It has a rounded beavertail and is comfortable even with a high, firm grip. One of those guns was a well-worn P220 European, the other, a brand new P220 American. In fact, the P245 takes the exact same spring used on the .40/.357 P239s (and the .40/.357 Sig Pros). Save my name and email to use for future comments. Please do us a favor and do not mix up Switzerland with Sweden. Add to Cart. The Rifle section is dedicated to James Henry Mason, aka forum member "horse"; shooter, collector and rifle authority, who left us too soon. April 22, 2023 03:35 AM. I later hit the 1-inch mark at 25 yards with a 5-inch SAO P220 and inexpensive MagTech 230 grain FMJ. The SIG P220 was eventually adopted as the Swiss Pistol 75 in 9mm Parabellum. Sig Sauer P220 Full Size. The first thing that jumps out is the two-tone look is the result of combining an anodized barrel, action, and slide combined with a Flat Dark Earth alloy frame . I also like the way it shoots better. The SIG is a bigger frame, fatter grip, obviously very different trigger. Don't get me wrong, I love 1911s. I don't think they have any 220. 1911; AR-15 Pistols; AK-47 Pistols; Pistol Brace Guns; Other Handguns; Rifles Rifles. The P220, which is also available with an E2 grip, is significantly more slender and maneuverable. SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. Grayguns Fat Guide Rod - Sig P320 Full Size - Stainless. The model we are reviewing today is a .45 ACP model. . . Taken into service as the "Automatic Pistol, Caliber .45, M1911," it would go on to become the most respected combat handgun of all . Naturally it is not made anymore because it was quality. First is Colt 1911 Government 45 ACP in blued finish, 5" bbl, two mags, blue case manual lock everything that it came with. Price $19.99. The M1911 (also known as Colt 1911, or Colt Government) is a single-action, semi-automatic, magazine-fed, recoil-operated pistol chambered for the .45 ACP cartridge. Four shots went into roughly 1-1/4 inches. (1) A fan of SIGs compact single-stack 9mm, Mullin added, Although the P220 is not as good as a P225, I would rate it the top weapon that I tested in .45 ACP. (Mullins emphasis.). I have both a Colt Delta Elite and a. I checked my gun safe and I have to stand both corrected and chastised regarding my original post. Posted: 7/29/2012 8:05:48 AM EDT. I will say this though ever since first shooting my sig I haven't shot any other handgun. Subsequent shots are single action, giving you a light and short trigger pull until the gun is decocked. My finger simply needs to leave the trigger and rotate slightly to hit the magazine release and drop the mag. Citadel 1911 Review: Best Budget-Friendly Pistol? I own a Glock 21, and while I like it, the grip is that of a brick, it feels terrible in my hand, it has had several failures to eject over the years, the trigger is spongy, and its not as accurate as my P220. But it is a lot to lug around for a day or two of hiking. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. The P220 Carry is a shortened version of the full-size P220. The P220 has an overall length of 7.8 inches, is 1.5 inches wide, and is 5.5 inches high. DPMS LR-308 [Review]: The AR, Back to Basics. You will not be regretting it. Its both tactile and audible and very nice overall. I have to change recoil springs to go from modern weak 10mm to "real" 10mm in the Glock and the 1911. It holds eight rounds of .45 ACP in a single stack magazine. Originally designed as a military pistol, it necessitated extreme accuracy and the Girsan MC P35 does not disappoint. The SIG Sauer P220 is a semi-automatic pistol. The Sig P220 was the same basic concept as the Colt: a single-stack .45 ACP full sized combat pistol. My biggest complaint is related to my preference for a nice high grip. The P220 is 100% reliable with any 10mm ammo. Go. These guns are big soft shooting, accurate, and reliable babies. Design. I can tell you from extensive experience with both platforms that the Sig P220, no matter its vintage, will run pretty much whatever ammo you can put through it like greased corn runs through a goose. (If you want a more direct comparison between the Legion and non-Legion Sigs, take a look at our review of the Sig P226 and P226 Legion.) 1. The history on those two pistols I cited doesn't change just because you don't like the narrative, and a supposedly 'newer, awesomer' version doesn't make the previous version less prone to failure with the full power 10mm ammo (Norma 10mm and other) the FBI and others were testing with at that time. While I haven't read about the barrel link, I would think it is also a weak spot for 1911 in 10mm. The tank of 10mm semi auto pistols was the 3rd generation S&W 1006/1076 varieties & then the SIg P220 R 5 10mm came to be 4-5 years ago by Lipsey's in LA. Get 12 Issues a year of the country's best firearms writing. I'm Mike, one of the oldest writer of Sniper Country! As a modern combat handgun its lacking. Please consider creating a new thread. Sig Sauer even provides a thumb-operated de-cocking lever to let the operator accomplish this safety. Once the first shot had been fired, it went to single-action, where the trigger press was a clean, easy 4 to 6pounds or so. They shoot where you want and feed almost anything. With a 4.41-inch barrel, the SIG was a little longer in that dimension than the 4.25-inch Colt Commander, but more than half an inch shorter than the 5-inch Government Model. or quality 1911 (Awesome/Expensive!) With the Sig, most generally you will not need a set of files to swap parts. This classic has been reborn, with the same quality, accuracy and reliability that the Swiss Army has relied on for decades. Only when a custom gunsmith (or, beginning in the 1990s, the manufacturers) put a beavertail grip safety on the lightweight 1911 did it become as comfortable to shoot as a P220, and allow the shooter to take advantage of the reduced muzzle jump potential afforded by its lower bore axis. $20.00. While the world has moved to 9mm pistols and polymer-frame guns, the SIG P220 is a defiant old man telling kids to get off his lawn. Conclusion. The trigger is brilliant in both double action and single action modes. Interestingly enough in the United States, the P220 is mostly known for being a .45 ACP handgun. For those unfamiliar with the P220, it is the handgun the company's current stable of pistols owe their heritage to. Add to Cart. In my own testing although accuracy was good (at least with the German Made guns) the P226 9mm was always inferior to old fashioned classic guns like the Original High Power or Neuhausen P210 or CZ 75 or THE FABULOUS STAR MODEL 30 which was the BEST HANDGUN OF THE 20TH/21st.CENTURY which actually endured 180,000 round wear tests, try that with any other modern plasticky or stamped sheet metal pistol. The 1911 was never built for the round. It is about the same weight as the six-shot Smith & Wesson Model 10 or Model 64 Military & Police revolver with a 2-inch barrel. Join 212,000 avid gun enthusiasts and claim your print-at-home shooting drills. Get gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and updates on law changes daily! -. Some 1911s will handle it very well if they are built well, others maybe not so much over the long haul. As you can probably tell, the P220 SAO is my favorite in either caliber. In your opinion, which frame handles the 10mm better? The SIG P220 Carry is an obvious commitment to handgun manufacture as there are many different versions of this handgun. Very interesting question! The main spring of this gun is a throw back to one of the biggest turkeys of a handgun ever invented the P38. 3. I may head to the range this weekend and rent a 1911. Its a big gun designed for duty, not concealed carry (Best CCW Guns). I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. Conclusion: Is the SIG Sauer P220 a Good Gun? The pistol was originally developed for the Swiss Army, and officially adopted by them in 1975, chambered in 9mm. ~Mele Kalikimaka me ka Hauoli Makahiki Hou~. The P220 is a bit dated by todays standards but people still love the gun, and it has a worthy place in the history of modern combat handguns.
Is Rachel Sanderson Married, Articles S